Metal Roofing vs Asphalt Shingle Roofing: A Complete Guide

Choosing between metal and asphalt roofing is one of the most important decisions a homeowner will make. Your roof not only protects your home but also impacts its energy efficiency, curb appeal, maintenance needs, and long-term value.

Home Genius Exteriors specializes in both premium metal roofing and top-tier asphalt shingle roofing, offering solutions tailored to meet your goals.

Here’s a full breakdown to help you decide if metal roofing or asphalt shingles are right for you.

The Advantages Of Metal Roofing

Longevity and Durability

Metal roofing installed by Home Genius Exteriors is engineered for exceptional lifespan and resilience. 

A properly installed metal roof can last anywhere from 50 to 70+ years, far outpacing traditional roofing materials. Home Genius uses technologies like MasterRib® panels, which feature extra-wide ribs for structural strength. These metal roofs resist rust, corrosion, chalking, fading, cracking, mold, mildew, and stains. Additionally, they boast the highest UL ratings for fire resistance, wind resistance, and impact performance, making them an ideal choice for severe weather zones.

Energy Efficiency Advantages

Energy savings are another hallmark of Home Genius metal roofs. Equipped with the Signature® 200 Paint System, these roofs feature cool roof-compliant colors that reflect a significant portion of solar energy. This reduces attic temperatures and lowers home cooling costs, especially during hot summers. They are ENERGY STAR® certified, maintaining at least 15% reflectivity even after three years of exposure. Homeowners can enjoy not only a durable roof but also noticeable reductions in energy bills.

Materials and Style Options

When it comes to customization, Home Genius offers a wide variety of choices. Metal panels are available in different profiles, including MasterRib, Advantage-Lok II, 5V, and 7/8″ Corrugated. Customers can select from up to 20 Signature® 200 and 300 color options, with metal gauges ranging from 22 to 29 GA. Aluminum panels are also available for additional corrosion resistance. Whether you prefer a sleek, contemporary look or something more traditional, there’s a style to suit every home.

Low Maintenance Requirements

One of the most attractive features of metal roofing is its low maintenance needs. Thanks to the durable Galvalume® coating—a combination of steel, aluminum, and zinc—metal roofs require minimal upkeep to remain in excellent condition for decades.

Aesthetic Versatility

Metal roofs offer a clean, modern aesthetic that can complement contemporary architecture, yet they are equally capable of delivering classic farmhouse charm or colonial appeal. The broad range of profiles and colors allows homeowners to match their roof precisely to their personal style and the character of their home.

The Advantages of Asphalt Shingle Roofing

Affordability of Asphalt Shingle Roofing

One of the biggest advantages of asphalt shingle roofing is its affordability. Compared to other roofing materials like metal, asphalt shingles have a significantly lower upfront cost, making them an ideal choice for homeowners on a tighter budget. The combination of widespread availability, easier installation, and competitive pricing means you can achieve a high-quality, durable roof without a major financial investment. Even premium shingle options with enhanced features remain more budget-friendly than most alternative roofing systems, helping you protect your home while keeping project costs manageable.

Advanced Brand and Technology

Home Genius Exteriors installs only Owens Corning® shingles, a name synonymous with quality and innovation in the roofing industry. Owens Corning shingles incorporate SureNail® Technology, a patented fabric strip that enhances nailing precision and increases wind resistance up to 130 MPH. StreakGuard® technology, with its copper-lined granules, helps resist algae growth, maintaining the roof’s appearance and structural integrity over time. A triple-layer protection system ensures durability against the elements.

A Complete Roofing System

Home Genius doesn’t just install shingles; they build a full roofing system. This includes underlayments, shingles, proper ventilation, and flashing systems. Key product lines like the Duration® Collection offer architectural shingles with a rich, dimensional look and exceptional weather resistance. For areas prone to hail or severe weather, products like Duration FLEX® and Duration STORM® provide enhanced impact resistance with Class 4 ratings.

Energy Efficiency and Attic Health

While asphalt shingles themselves don’t reflect solar energy as efficiently as metal, the full system approach used by Home Genius significantly improves a home’s overall energy performance. Proper attic ventilation through VentSure® products reduces heat buildup and moisture, preventing ice dams and mold growth. High-quality underlayments like Titanium® and RhinoRoof® further protect against water infiltration and wind-driven rain.

Wide Aesthetic Variety

Owens Corning shingles come in a broad palette of TruDefinition® colors, providing vibrant, lasting hues that elevate your home’s curb appeal. Whether you’re looking for a bold architectural statement or a traditional, muted tone, there’s a shingle style to match.

Expert Installation and Comprehensive Warranty

Home Genius Exteriors holds Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor status, which ensures expert installation and access to some of the best roofing warranties available. Homeowners can have peace of mind knowing that their investment is backed by both superior workmanship and strong manufacturer guarantees.

Direct Comparison: Metal vs Asphalt Shingles

Which Roofing Option is Right for You?

Why Choose Metal Roofing?

Homeowners looking for maximum durability, energy efficiency, and a long-term investment often find metal roofing to be the best choice. It requires very little maintenance, resists extreme weather conditions, and provides a modern aesthetic that can dramatically boost property value. Although the initial cost is higher, the extended lifespan and minimal upkeep often make metal roofing the more economical choice over decades.

Metal roofing is ideal if you plan to stay in your home long-term, want to reduce your environmental footprint, or desire a bold, contemporary look. It’s particularly well-suited for homes in areas prone to wildfires, hurricanes, or extreme heat.

Why Choose Asphalt Shingle Roofing?

Asphalt shingle roofing remains the most popular choice for many homeowners due to its affordability, wide stylistic range, and reliable performance. With advances like SureNail® Technology and StreakGuard®, today’s asphalt shingles offer durability that far exceeds older models. Shingle roofs are quicker and easier to install, making them a great choice if you’re on a tighter timeline or budget.

Asphalt shingles are ideal if you appreciate traditional home aesthetics, want a lower upfront investment, and value a strong warranty backed by a nationally recognized brand like Owens Corning.

Final Thoughts: You Can’t Go Wrong with Home Genius Exteriors

Whether you choose metal roofing or asphalt shingles, Home Genius Exteriors delivers top-quality materials, expert installation, and outstanding customer service. Each option offers unique advantages depending on your specific priorities—be it longevity, aesthetics, budget, or sustainability.

If you’re unsure which roof type is right for you, Home Genius Exteriors can help. Contact their team for a personalized consultation. They’ll review your budget, goals, and style preferences to recommend the perfect solution for your home.

Ready to transform your roof and boost your home’s value?

Reach out to Home Genius Exteriors today for a free quote and expert advice tailored to your needs.